Get In Touch

Blog

The Newsroom You’re Pitching No Longer Exists

Every day, our team sends pitches into what can feel like press oblivion — refining media lists, tailoring language to each reporter, doing the dogged work this industry has always required. Increasingly, though, we’re finding that effort misaligned with the newsrooms those pitches are meant to reach.

According to Muck Rack’s 2026 State of PR report, 71% of PR professionals say low journalist response rates are making earned media harder to secure, while 61% point to shrinking media lists.

That contraction reaches newsrooms at every level of prestige. Newspaper industry employment has fallen more than 75% since 2005. Whatever remained of print’s golden age has given way to a far more gilded reality. Local desks are thinning out; specialist beats are being absorbed into broader assignments and editors are prioritizing exclusive reporting.

We must stop treating a media list as a static asset. It now has to function as a live map of where journalistic attention exists, what reporters are being asked to produce and where a client’s story actually fits.

Local outlets have long been a natural home for community stories and organization-driven news. But that ecosystem is shrinking as public media funding declines and newspapers continue to disappear. As a result, many communities, especially smaller and rural ones, have fewer trusted outlets covering the people, organizations and issues closest to home.

A local announcement may still be newsworthy even when fewer reporters have the time or mandate to cover it. When relevant, we look to connect it to a broader regional trend, policy debate or national event. Take a solar nonprofit offering grants to help Jewish institutions switch to solar power. On its own, that may be a hyper-local story. But when tied to the growing strain AI data centers are placing on the electric grid and rising energy costs, the client’s story becomes a microcosm of a much larger national challenge, and a potential solution.

Even when an outlet survives, specialization may not. For nearly a decade, Liam Dillon covered housing affordability and neighborhood change for the Los Angeles Times. When he left for Politico in 2025 to continue covering California housing, the Times did not replace him. Coverage of the beat at the Times shifted across reporters on real estate, affordability, homelessness, politics and local government – a reminder that even when a reporter keeps their specialty, we have to follow the person, not just the masthead.

These changes force us to make targeting more interpretive. A housing story may belong with a real estate reporter, city hall reporter or politics reporter depending on the news. Recent clips, and current responsibilities matter more than the beat label attached to a reporter’s name.

Newsrooms are also becoming more selective about what deserves scarce reporting time and resources.

Business Insider has made that shift explicit after facing traffic declines and repeated restructuring. It has moved away from aggregation and toward original reporting in areas where it believes it can be indispensable – reporters who once rewrote or summarized news from elsewhere are now expected to own beats, independently source stories and move narratives forward. Earlier this year, Business Insider made it clear what it wants from PR teams: exclusives, access to executives and irreplicable reporting. USA Today is responding to similar stressors. In September, leadership told staff that simply producing more content is no longer an effective audience-growth strategy as search traffic declines and AI models keep more users inside their own platforms.

For us, the implication is straightforward. The standard press release has less power when a newsroom is being rewarded for distinctiveness. When our clients’ stories can support it, we offer embargoed access, proprietary data, original research, strong case studies or meaningful source access. If a release is the deliverable, we must show reporters we respect their constraints by providing clean facts, credible sources, useful context, visuals and a clear reason why the story matters now.

PR has always required persistence. But as reporters, beats and distribution channels grow unrecognizable, persistence only works if there is still someone on the other end of the pitch.